View Summary
Issues:
Employer liability, workers' compensation, evidence, policy and procedure, safety, service provider's liability.
Case Summary:
An employee of General Electric appeals a lower court's ruling in suit against a physician contracted by the company to review employee X-rays. GE contracted with Dr. C. Vernon Williamson to review X-rays that were required for workers involved with particular tasks. Willard Hoover, a GE employee, worked for many years in a position that exposed him to silica dust. Hoover filed suit against Williamson, claiming the physician failed to advise him that his X-rays indicated development of an illness related to exposure to the dust. Hoover contended that Williamson annually reviewed the X-rays and approved Hoover for continued work. Williamson asserted the only relationship involved in this case concerned his contract with GE, not with workers whose X-rays he reviewed.
Decision of lower jurisdiction:
The Superior Court of Baltimore found for Dr. Williams, ruling no doctor-patient relationship existed between Williams and the individual employees of GE. Hoover now appeals.
Outcome:
Hoover wins. The Maryland Court of Appeals ruled the lower jurisdiction erred in handling the case. The appeals court remanded the case to the lower jurisdiction for appropriate action.