View Summary
Issues:
Workers' compensation, random drug screening, alcohol, injury
Case Summary:
The City of Norfolk appeals a state commission's decision to award medical benefits to city employee. Janet Vaughan, struck her on the rear door frame of a municipal vehicle as she was returning from a random drug test. Vaughan petitioned for benefits for lost time. A hearing officer rejected her initial request. She then appealed to a review board.
Decision of lower jurisdiction:
The state's Workers' Compensation Commission ruled the injury was related to Vaughn's employment and granted medical benefits. The city now appeals.
Outcome:
Norfolk wins. The Virginia Court of Appeals reversed and dismissed the commission's ruling.