View Summary
RICHFOOD INC. and Old Republic Insurance Company
vs.
James A. WILLIAMS.
Click Here to Read the Full Case Summary
Issues:
Workers' compensation, return to duty.
Case Summary:
Richfood Inc. and its insurer, Old Republic Insurance Co. appeal a decision of the state's Workers' Compensation Commission that extends partial disability benefits to James A. Williams, a former employee who was fired for failing a drug test.
Decision of lower jurisdiction:
The Workers' Compensation Commission ruled in favor of Williams and awarded him partial benefits. The commission noted that Williams had a previous workers' compensation history and based its award on his previous performance
Outcome:
Richfood wins. The Virginia Court of Appeals reversed the commission's ruling. The court noted that Williams was discharged for cause.